I'm in a true conundrum

Try exposing him to bits of your truth continually over a couple of months before coming clean... use real subtle hints. If his harsh prejudice is broken even a little beforehand, then his shock will be easier to overcome.
He will probably try to convert you at first, but please be patient. It's a terrible feeling when you have to believe people you care for are facing eternal damnation. I remember.

I'm facing similar problems at the moment. Even though I'm still a Christian, just the fact of me practicing witchcraft could get me shunned. I'm just trying to break it slowly to them. I know that they'll still chill with me and everything, we're all mature people after all, but I still think that they'll kinda shy away from me after I tell them. Like I'm a crazy or something. We have hard lives XD lol

information, like any commodity can be hoarded or it can be spread freely.

It is your choice to weigh the scales, measure the vials, and see with a clear eye what is the most profitable course.


Of course, nothing ventured is nothing gained ;)