yet another riddle

there is an island tht is inhabited by knights and knaves. knights must always tell the truth and knaves must always tell a lie. one day a stranger visits the island on a boat and calls out are you a knight or a knave the first person calls back but the visitor cant hear him so he repeats the question. the second man calls out he is a knight as so am i. however the third person calls out he is not a knight he is a knave like me.

figure out who the three people are either knights or knaves or mixture of both

Login or Signup to reply to this post.

That doesn't make sense.. the third guy.. if he's a knight, then he tells the truth, that he's a knave.. but as a Knave, he lies... so he's lieing about himself being a knave!?
The third guy has got me confused..

sir has nerly got it just need to think about what he has put nd then the answer will be revealed

the first guy is a knight
the second guy is the knave
and the third guy is neather he is the guy that got stuck on an island with two cannables rofl

LOL...does one of each have to be a knight,knave and mixture of both??

b/c I was gonna say
3rd is mixed
2nd is knave
1st is knave
or
3rd- knave
2nd-mixed
1st-knight...

ok if you want i will tell you the answer

ya

no need there 2 knaves 1 knight

The third person and the first are knights, The second is a knave???? whats the answer?????

the First and the second are knights the third is a knave